Seattle News

19-11-2026

West Seattle Families Fear Merger of Two Elementary Schools

Families of students at Sanislo Elementary in West Seattle are once again worried about the school’s future. Two years ago, they managed to stop a plan to close it. Now Seattle Public Schools, the district that oversees public schools throughout the city, is considering merging Sanislo with nearby Highland Park Elementary.

At a meeting with district Superintendent Ben Shuldiner, parents from both schools voiced their concerns and asked for more details. The merger is part of a broader reorganization plan that could affect 21 schools. In evaluating options, the district is considering enrollment, building capacity, costs, population projections and the impact on families. Shuldiner says the goal is to improve education, not simply cut costs.

Highland Park has 305 students, while Sanislo has 122. According to the district’s calculations, a combined school could have a full-time social worker, music teachers and art teachers—specialists currently in short supply at both schools. Sanislo teachers have been promised positions at the merged school if enrollment is high enough to preserve those jobs; if enrollment drops, they could be transferred to other schools. Shuldiner assured families there would be no layoffs.

Sanislo parents fear a merger would break the close ties between families and school staff. Manélin Fwang Feth, who attended Sanislo herself and now sends her two children there, described how the school nurse, social worker and other staff supported her family after a difficult childbirth. Highland Park parents, meanwhile, are concerned about the school’s leadership: during the first year, both schools’ principals would work together, after which, under the usual rule, the more experienced principal would remain.

Some families believe the district should first have considered other ways to increase enrollment, including changing school attendance boundaries. Most children are assigned to schools based on boundaries that take into account capacity, enrollment and program availability, so a school’s proximity to home does not always determine where a child is assigned. If the nearest school is overcrowded, closed or does not offer the right program, a student may be placed farther away. Shuldiner acknowledged that boundary changes could affect school assignments but noted that they would affect many more families.

Parents also point to years of maintenance problems at Sanislo, including a leaking roof and poorly maintained restrooms. Opinions on the merger are divided: a former head of Sanislo’s parent committee supported consolidation to expand educational opportunities, but urged the district to ensure Highland Park has strong leadership and to provide transportation for families.

For some children, the trip to the new school would take nearly half an hour by bus instead of a short walk. Travel between neighborhoods in West Seattle can be especially difficult: the peninsula is separated from the central part of the city by Elliott Bay and connected to it by a limited number of bridges, including the West Seattle Bridge. Waiting for a bus, making transfers and walking to a stop can add even more time to the journey.

The district plans to finish meeting with families by mid-December and then present its recommendations to the school board. Administrators are preparing reorganization options, and parents, school staff and residents will have a chance to share their views at public hearings. The elected school board makes the final decision: hearings are expected in January and February, with a vote in late February or early March.

Based on: West Seattle families question school closure proposal