After the recent victory of supporters of a tax on millionaires’ incomes, Washington state Senate Majority Leader Jamie Pedersen proposed considering another tax reform: replacing the existing business tax with a corporate income tax. For now, it is only an idea. Pedersen says a bill is unlikely to appear before 2028.
Washington’s business and occupation (B&O) tax is assessed on gross revenue, not profit, so companies often have to pay it even when they are losing money. It applies to a wide range of business activities, with rates varying by category. The system generates substantial revenue for the state and is relatively easy to administer, but it places a heavier burden on businesses with low profit margins and companies with long chains of resale transactions. In many other states, the main tax on companies is levied on net income, with expenses deductible.
Pedersen believes switching to a tax on profits could make the rules clearer and more uniform. He insists that the reform should be revenue-neutral and not increase overall tax receipts. But introducing such a tax depends on a court ruling: in 1933, the state Supreme Court held in Culliton v. Chase that income from property is itself property and must be taxed under the applicable rules. Constitutional requirements for uniformity and limits on tax rates have made it much harder to introduce a conventional income tax.
A tax on income above $1 million a year is currently being challenged in court. If the court allows it, that could change the legal basis for taxing income and pave the way for a corporate income tax. Otherwise, lawmakers will likely have to continue seeking revenue through taxes on business activity, such as the B&O tax.
The stakes are high: the B&O tax brings in about $7 billion a year, roughly 19% of all tax revenue and nearly twice the amount expected from the millionaires’ tax. According to the state Department of Revenue, in 2020 the corporate tax rate would have had to be 15.8% to replace the revenue collected under the old system. By comparison, the average top rate in states with such a tax is 6.6%.
Business representatives doubt the state would truly limit itself to a revenue-neutral reform, especially given its recurring budget shortfalls. Companies are also concerned about losing tax breaks under the B&O system. It includes special rates and provisions for manufacturing, retail, services, insurance, agriculture and mining, along with specific deductions and exemptions—for example, for certain transactions between manufacturers and wholesalers, some agricultural income, and small businesses that meet certain criteria. Keeping these measures eases the burden on some industries but narrows the tax base; eliminating them could simplify the system while increasing costs for companies that currently benefit from them.
Some experts see the switch as a potentially significant reform: businesses have long criticized the tax on gross receipts, though the ultimate effects will depend on the details of any proposal. There is also no consensus within the progressive camp: unions and other groups are calling for a more sweeping overhaul of the tax system and want additional revenue directed to health care, education and public services.
Pedersen acknowledges that many issues remain to be resolved, from rates and tax breaks to how the tax would interact with local taxes. The debate will therefore take time, and a legislative proposal is unlikely to emerge before 2028 or 2029.
Based on: A corporate income tax in WA? Top Democratic lawmaker floats the idea